Pizza in New Haven, CT

When you need some comfort food, pizza is a no-brainer. Fortunately, hungry locals can get their fill with the local pizza in New Haven, CT. Whichever pizzeria you choose, consider trying the coal-fired New-Haven style thin-crust this town is known for. Browse our local favorites brought to you by Mercedes-Benz of North Haven!

Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

Established in 1925, Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana was founded by Italian immigrant Frank Pepe who originated the New-Haven style thin-crust pizza. Opt for the seasonal fresh tomato pie (available July-September) or year-round flavors like the white clam pizza or veggie special. You may be surprised to find that your pizza doesn’t come cut in equal pizzas like a traditional pie; this is to allow for diners who don’t eat as much (like children) to pick the perfectly-sized slice.

Modern Apizza

Another pizzeria with a long history in the New Haven community is Modern Apizza. If you’re up for trying unique flavor combinations like the seafood supreme or American cheese pizza, this is your pizza destination. Traditional pizzas are also served, along with calzones, dinners, and grinders. Gluten-free crusts are available for those with allergies.

Yorkside Pizza Restaurant

A student favorite, Yorkside Pizza Restaurant has a menu of pizza, Greek food, and more in a casual environment with old pictures in the background. Dough and sauces are made fresh daily, and customers will be more than satisfied by their generous portions and affordable pricing.

BAR

The music-loving 21 and over crowd love BAR. Inside this industrial-chic space, guests can enjoy drinks and indie rock shows along with their favorite pie. Recommended pizzas include the egg pizza and mashed potato pizza will give you the energy you need to dance the night away.

Sally’s Apizza

Lines can be long at this local hot spot, but for good reason. Sally’s Apizza doesn’t have a fancy atmosphere, but it’s attracted famous visitors like Frank Sinatra, Bill Clinton, and Kathleen Turner. Once you taste their made-to-order pies, you’ll understand what the fuss is about.

Enjoy the Best With Mercedes-Benz of North Haven!

At Mercedes-Benz of North Haven, we’re happy to be your New Haven guide. Once you’ve tried the best pizza in New Haven, CT, we can recommend other restaurants to add to your list. Need a little pick-me-up after the carbs? Try out one of the New Haven coffee shops!